"Love 'em and leave 'em" is the motto of this small town's football team whose goal is to pile up as many female conquests as possible, rank their looks based on a point system and then promptly discard them like damaged goods. This cruel game pushes some girls, like Lisa (Mena Suvari) over the edge... literally. Lisa commits suicide by leaping off of the roof of the school, and her best friend Rachel (Emily Bergl) seeks out the football player whose actions lead her to take her own life. In the process of finding justice for her friend, Rachel falls for another football player. She thinks the feeling is mutual, but little does she know that she too is just another pawn in their sick game. Unfortunately for them Rachel is developing telekinesis - a skill that will rear its ugly head on prom night, just like it did for the infamous Carrie White. The school's only savior can be found in Sue (Amy Irving) the guidance counselor, who survived the original massacre years earlier. But is it already too late?